Building a scientific and reasonable app bet365 download journal evaluation system
December 20, 2022 10:40 Source: "Chinese Social Sciences app bet365 download" Issue 2555, December 20, 2022 Author: Zhou Genhong

In recent years,The Party Central Committee attaches great importance to strengthening the construction of app bet365 download。May 9, 2021,General Secretary Xi Jinping’s reply to all the editorial staff of the "Literature, History and Philosophy" editorial board of Shandong University,Putting forward earnest expectations for running a journal of philosophy and social sciences;May 18, 2021,Central Propaganda Department、Ministry of Education、The Ministry of Science and Technology issued the "Opinions on Promoting the Prosperity and Development of app bet365 download",Provide institutional guidance for the development of app bet365 download in the new era。Promote the high-quality development of app bet365 download,The key is to explore and establish a scientific and reasonable academic journal evaluation system,Thus promoting academic innovation、Cultivating outstanding academic talents、Improve the international voice of app bet365 download、Building China’s independent knowledge system。

Improve the academic journal evaluation index system。Currently,Most of the evaluation indicators of app bet365 download are based on citation rate、Reprinted rate and other data are the main basis。For this,Some app bet365 download prefer to invite manuscripts from famous authors,Reduce the number of posts,Set job title、Education、Unit threshold,There is even a forced reference、False citations, false annotations, etc.。These behaviors are detrimental to the growth of academic talents、Academic innovation has had a negative impact。Promote the high-quality development of app bet365 download,Need to break with citation rate、An evaluation index system dominated by reprint rate,Create a set of policies with broad coverage、Comprehensive indicators、Scientific weighted evaluation system。First, further optimize the existing quantitative evaluation index system,Set different evaluation indicators according to the characteristics of different professional disciplines,Citation rate、Set different weight standards for quantitative indicators such as reprint rate, etc.。The second is to fully consider the comprehensive evaluation of the journal,Improve value leadership、Academic innovation、Author composition、Percentage of free submissions、Review mechanism、Evaluation indicators for editing team quality and other aspects,Thus fully reflecting the level of app bet365 download,Guide app bet365 download to establish the correct direction for running journals。

Establish a classification and evaluation system for app bet365 download。The number of app bet365 download in my country is huge,And there are big differences in app bet365 download of the same category。Overall,Can be roughly divided into comprehensive app bet365 download and subject app bet365 download。In subject app bet365 download,There are journals covering the entire subject,There are also journals that only focus on secondary subjects or a certain research field。Take the field of Chinese literature as an example,There are journals covering all disciplines,Also focuses on ancient literature、Modern Literature、Journal of contemporary literature,There is also a special study on Lu Xun、Guo Moruo、Du Fu、Journal of "A Dream of Red Mansions"。These app bet365 download have different research scopes、Theoretical methods and disciplinary value,The current evaluation system cannot fully demonstrate the unique value and academic creativity of various journals。Therefore,The evaluation criteria of app bet365 download should be continuously enriched,Taking into consideration the nature of the publication、Discipline Characteristics、Research scope and other aspects,Construct a classification evaluation system,Set more detailed evaluation criteria。First, professional disciplines are used as the main basis for constructing the academic journal evaluation index system,Set up an evaluation index system suitable for different professional disciplines based on their characteristics。The second is to evaluate based on subject characteristics,Especially the research results of some basic research and unpopular secrets,We should focus on its academic innovation、Academic value、Improve the evaluation index system in terms of social and cultural guidance。

Establish an evaluation system that combines quantitative and qualitative methods。Currently,Some academic journal evaluations simply use quantitative indicators as evaluation criteria,Resulting in some excellent app bet365 download recognized in the academic community because of low citation rates、Excluded from "core journals" due to narrow subject coverage and other reasons。The evaluation of app bet365 download should be a comprehensive evaluation of app bet365 download,Involving the content quality of app bet365 download、Brand reputation、Academic influence、Academic innovation、Author team and other diverse elements。Improve the evaluation system of app bet365 download,A set of quantitative and qualitative evaluation mechanisms should be established。First, establish a qualitative review expert database,Make full use of the academic advantages of experts and scholars in various disciplines,Exploring an academic journal evaluation system that combines quantitative evaluation and expert evaluation。The second is to strengthen the selection of peer review experts,Focus on the academic level of review experts、Review performance、Credibility, etc. will be evaluated accordingly。Establish a review expert evaluation credibility system,Ensure the objectivity of evaluation。

  (This article is the guidance app bet365 download National Social Science Fund key project "Implementing the Quality Improvement Project of Literary and Artistic Works、Research on Institutional Design and Practical Innovation” (21AZD054) Phased Results)

(Author’s unit: School of Liberal Arts, Shandong University)

Editor: Zhang Jing
二维码图标2.jpg
Highly recommended
Latest article
app bet365 download

Friendly links:

Website registration number: Beijing Public Network Security No. 11010502030146 Ministry of Industry and Information Technology:

All rights reserved by China app bet365 download Magazine. No reproduction or use without permission is allowed

Chief editor’s email: zzszbj@126.com Contact information of this website: 010-85886809 Address: Floor 11-12, app bet365 download 1, No. 15 Guanghua Road, Chaoyang District, Beijing Postal Code: 100026