Beautiful improper increase citations requirements
August 09, 2023 09:30 Source: "China Social Sciences", August 9, 2023, Issue 2709 Author: Practice

Bet365 app download  The official website of "Nature" magazine recently posted a document,A latest study display,Many scholars have been edited and asked to add citation to the manuscript,If you accept this requirement, it is more likely to successfully publish the paper。

Article representation,The interviewed by this study is 1160 scholars,In a 2012 study, they proposed that they had been required to add additional citation,Among them, 1043 people added at least one citation。Based on bet365 best casino games the investigation in 2012,Researchers discovered,1/5 scholars in the social sciences and business fields have said they had similar experiences。Researchers think,Considering the situation reflected in the survey results, no major changes have occurred,This result still has importance today。

According to the latest research,The author of the reference content fully according to the requirements of the editor,The pass rate of its work is 85%,Partial acceptance is 77%,The pass rate of the article refused to accept is only 39%。If the researcher agrees to increase the content that should not exist,So in the future, it is very likely to submit to the journal and continue bet365 Play online games to add citation。Researchers who have not received such requirements,68%believe that it is unlikely that you will submit such requirements in the future,And this data only accounts for 47%of the researchers who have received such requirements。

Researchers said,This phenomenon appears,It may be because the editor tries to improve the journal or its work of its own works,or peer evaluation experts want to persuade the author to quote his work。This is easy to trigger the problem of citation raing,That is a number of scholars or multiple journals reached an agreement,Promise to a large number of dissertations of each other to increase the quantity。but but,There Bet365 app download are also some reasonable situations,Especially in the relatively niche research field,Pass review expert or editor may ask the author to refer to a dissertation and quote。

Relevant scholars think,One of the solutions to this kind of problem is to exclude the self -introduction rate of the journal outside the impact factor indicator of the journal,This is here,Journal editing may not require adding citations。This is because of,Many times,Requirement to add specific citations is not to make amendments based on the article itself,If you want to reduce these improper behaviors,Motivation must be eliminated。In addition,publishers bet365 live casino games and journals are also responsible for strengthening training for editing or peer evaluation experts,Do a good job of supervision at the same time。If the publisher and journal are out of office,No supervision work,Scholars and society should respond,Can complain to relevant institutions,Third -party institutions should act as the role of supervisor。

(Practicing Zhi Shi/Compilation)

Editor in charge: Zhang Jing
QR code icons 2.jpg
Key recommendation
The latest article
Graphics
bet365 live casino games
Video

Friendship link:

Website filing number: Jinggong.com Anxie 11010502030146 Ministry of Industry and Information Technology:

All rights reserved by China Social Sciences Magazine shall not be reprinted and used without permission

General Editor Email: bet365 best casino games zzszbj@126.com This website Contact information: 010-85886809 Address: 11-12, Building 1, Building 1, No. 15, Guanghua Road, Chaoyang District, Beijing: 100026