Journal Editor's spontaneous article quotes
February 03, 2023 09:51 Source: "China Social Sciences", February 3, 2023, Issue 2582, Issue 2582

Our Comprehensive Foreign Media Report the official website of the British scientific journal "Nature" recently reported,A new study discovery,Many journal editors are publishing academic articles in the journal they are responsible for,The so -called "spontaneous"。This research "Frequency and Self -Publication in Academic Editing" is published in "Nature · Human Behavior"。

Journal editors decide which manuscripts to enter the review、Which reviewers are selected、How to handle the review after the review,They have a considerable Bet365 app download impact on scholars' careers。Although well -known journals generally have full -time editors,But the editor of most journals is the scholar。Researchers collected the name and work unit data of 103,000 editors published in Elsevier,Compared with the published records of 2,1600 editors in the academic publication database "Microsoft Academic Map" compared to,To determine the affiliation of the editor、Published history and academic age, that is, the number of years since the first publication。The scale of the research on this study is in terms of survey academic spontaneous aspect,Have a large international influence。

Analysis results indicate,Although most journal editors are not spontaneous,but 12%editors,Its 20%academic bet365 Play online games achievements are published in the journal you are responsible for editing。In the position of editor -in -chief,This trend is more obvious,19%of the editor of 20%of its academic achievements is spontaneous,11%of the editor -in -chief of its academic achievement is spontaneous。where,The most extreme example is,A scholar published a lot of academic achievements in the same journal during the editor,72%of its total results。Research also found,Men's self -publishing probability and number of self -publishing probability and quantity,and concentrated in the time after editing。

Researchers said,spontaneous prevalence may exacerbate the problem of academic inequality,But it is really bet365 best casino games difficult to manage spontaneity。On the one hand,Some people think,When there are no other journals studied by the editor, there are no other journals to publish,or a senior scholar wants to help promote a newly found journal,Self -evolution is completely acceptable。On the other hand,Some people also feel that external contributors cannot determine whether the content of the editor will be given preferentially。This study also pointed out some cases that editors were suspended due to improper practice,For example, a large number of self -quotes,Or ask the author to quote a large number of his own works。

Researchers suggest,According to the current research results,Journal is necessary to adjust the selection bet365 live casino games of editors。They have proposed some experimental measures,For example,Randomly draws the final article editing from the candidate editor through the lottery。They also recommend establishing a more transparent rules and regulations for spontaneously,This can increase the credibility of the spontaneous article,It can also promote fairness between journal authors。Researchers call for the establishment of a "more fair、More transparent、More tolerant scientific editing culture ",And future research should pay attention to changes in journal publishing policies and their spontaneous influence on editing。

(Practice Zezhi Leisure/Compilation)

Editor in charge: Cui Cen
QR code icons 2.jpg
Key recommendation
The latest article
Graphics
bet365 live casino games

Friendship link:

Website filing number: Jinggong.com Anmi 11010502030146 bet365 Play online games Ministry of Industry and Information Technology:

All rights reserved by China Social Sciences Magazine shall not be reproduced and used without permission

General Editor Email: zzszbj@126.com This website contact information: 010-85886809 Address: Building 11-12, Building 1, Building 1, No. 15, Guanghua Road, Chaoyang District, Beijing: 100026