Constructing an academic discourse system with Chinese characteristics、In the historical process of promoting Chinese academics to the world,Academic journals are like a flag,Responsible for leading academic development、Important function to promote academic progress。Then,What kind of academic journal is a good journal、In order to play such a role?In other words,What kind of academic journal bet365 kentucky bonus code system do we need??On this topic,The reporter recently interviewed the editors-in-chief of many academic journals and some scholars who have long been engaged in journal bet365 kentucky bonus code practice and research。
Looking at journal bet365 kentucky bonus code from both sides
Current,A phenomenon attracts attention: on the one hand,The academic community expects academic journals to play an important role in promoting theoretical innovation and academic progress,On the other hand,The academic community is quite dissatisfied with the existing academic journal bet365 kentucky bonus code system,Some bet365 kentucky bonus code standards have been repeatedly questioned、Being criticized,I don’t seem to know how to evaluate the quality of academic journals。Actually,Those who are questioned mainly include the following points:
First, only the "foreign" index follows suit.
“Foreign brands” are often regarded as “high-end goods”,The "foreign" indexes represented by SSCI and others are regarded as the "golden brand" in the minds of some people in our country's academic circles。Actually,Influential domestic journals often perform poorly in foreign bet365 kentucky bonus code systems such as SSCI。Because these bet365 kentucky bonus code systems mainly include English journals,Non-English journals are at a disadvantage。
Some people are calling,“Journal bet365 kentucky bonus code must be ‘in line with international standards’”。In fact,They don’t know much about foreign situations。Interviewed scholars think,It is important to learn from Western countries’ journal bet365 kentucky bonus code methods。However,The so-called "integration",First of all, there needs to be a set of internationally accepted "track" standards,But only this,There are big differences between countries and regions;Secondly,Western bet365 kentucky bonus code standards reflect their ideology、Cultural Tradition、Language habits, etc.。Use these standards to evaluate our journals and results,Obviously not suitable。
Ronald Russo, an internationally renowned scientometrician, learned that some people in Chinese academic circles were so obsessed with SSCI and so on、After worship,First he looked surprised,Then he expressed it to this reporter without hesitation,China and other developing countries should build their own bet365 kentucky bonus code systems,We cannot just follow the lead of the West, especially the American system。“SSCI cannot be regarded as the ‘only criterion’ for bet365 kentucky bonus code,Its role should not be exaggerated。”
The second is to "discuss heroes" quantitatively.
Currently,Greater influence in journal bet365 kentucky bonus code standards、Quantitative bet365 kentucky bonus code criteria are more commonly used。This method is widely adopted and has certain rationality,But there are also inherent flaws and limitations。Due to the complexity and variety of citations,Such as basic information、Negative citations etc. are difficult to identify in quantitative standards,Use purely or mainly quantitative rather than qualitative criteria to judge the quality of papers and even journals,The one-sidedness is obvious。
Wang Xingguosheng, executive deputy editor of "Journal of Shenzhen University (Humanities and Social Sciences Edition)",Using the so-called "quantified impact factors" as bet365 kentucky bonus code indicators,Ignores the spiritual connotation of the bet365 kentucky bonus code object and the spiritual content it produces。We must understand the boundaries and limits of various bet365 kentucky bonus code systems and standards、Possible value and congenital defects and shortcomings in operation, etc.。
Third, blindly exaggerate the “core” functions.
To some extent,“Core journals” represent the standard of bet365 kentucky bonus code journals,It is also an ideal platform for scholars, especially young scholars, to publish their research results。
However,The trend of blindly pursuing the “core” should be corrected。As understood,"Core Journal" was not originally a journal bet365 kentucky bonus code standard。This concept comes from the West,The original intention is in the sense of library and information,First of all, it is to provide reference for readers when reading,The second is the book management department and the library purchasing books、Provide reference range when subscribing to newspapers。Because there is no generally accepted journal bet365 kentucky bonus code standard,So some scientific research institutions、Management departments and others directly regard it as "guidelines",This method of "saving trouble",Enlarged the functions of core journals,At the same time, some unreasonable concepts emerged。
Accordingly,“Core journals” should work hard on bet365 kentucky bonus code quality,Publish it effectively and gain recognition from the bet365 kentucky bonus code community、Excellent articles leading bet365 kentucky bonus code development,Instead of blindly pursuing the "core" label。
Amid doubts,China’s academic bet365 kentucky bonus code system is improving、Under development,At present, the "Chinese Humanities and Social Sciences Core Journals Outline" of the Bibliometrics and Scientific bet365 kentucky bonus code Research Center of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences has been formed、Chinese Social Sciences Citation Index (CSSCI) from the China Social Sciences Research bet365 kentucky bonus code Center of Nanjing University、Multiple bet365 kentucky bonus code systems such as the "Overview of Chinese Core Journals" launched by Peking University Library and others。Facing a large number of bet365 kentucky bonus code systems,Some people think this is a "waste of resources"。
To this,Wei Changbao, Director of the Editorial Office of China Social Sciences Magazine said,Compared to the past,This reflects the progress in the bet365 kentucky bonus code of academic journals in our country。There was no special journal bet365 kentucky bonus code organization before、Professional bet365 kentucky bonus code standards,Or simply use administrative level as the standard,And now there are multiple standards、Organization、The situation of coexisting systems,Something is better than nothing;Professional、Academic standards,Stronger than only non-academic standards。In addition,Many interviewed scholars believe that,Only if there is a scientific bet365 kentucky bonus code system,It is more in line with the laws of academic development,Guarantee the objectivity of academic bet365 kentucky bonus code、Scientific。
Building a journal bet365 kentucky bonus code system suitable for national conditions
In many scientific research units,The bet365 kentucky bonus code of academic journals is linked to actual benefits,Resulting in some bet365 kentucky bonus code criteria and results being often used in a different way。Professor Shen Guchao of the School of Information Management of Nanjing University said,Many of these problems originate from the bet365 kentucky bonus code system,The shortcomings of the system in turn magnify the shortcomings of the tools,Don’t just “look at” tools。In addition,The chaos in the bet365 kentucky bonus code of academic journals is related to the impetuous trend of quick success and quick success that spreads in academia and even society。Therefore,Only "eliminate alienation",Restore the original appearance in academic journal bet365 kentucky bonus code,It is possible to eliminate academic chaos,Create an ecologically harmonious academic atmosphere。
Some scholars said,The bet365 kentucky bonus code system of academic journals in my country is at the beginning of its construction,Reference、Learn the Western Journal bet365 kentucky bonus code System,Especially the bet365 kentucky bonus code system of Western natural sciences,It is inevitable,But we should respond actively、Solve the problems that occurred during the process,Speedly build an academic journal bet365 kentucky bonus code system suitable for national conditions。
Reporter learned,Many academic journal bet365 kentucky bonus code agencies are currently making adjustments、Under development。bet365 kentucky bonus code tools of various journals are also learning from each other、Learn from each other’s strengths。Also,Well-known publications in domestic academic journals are also striving to assume the leading academic mission,Building an academic brand,Jointly promote the scientific process of academic journal bet365 kentucky bonus code。
November 30, 2013,By China Social Sciences Magazine、Sponsored by Jiangsu Academy of Social Sciences,The "Second National Humanities and Social Sciences Journal High-Level Forum" with the theme of "Academic Journals and Academic bet365 kentucky bonus code" was held in Wuxi。Participating scholars emphasized,Academic journals should really focus on the content,Effectively improve the quality of publication,In order to truly give full play to the bet365 kentucky bonus code of academic journals in theoretical innovation and academic progress、Leading、Promotion。This is also the concept that should be highlighted in the bet365 kentucky bonus code of academic journals。
The Chinese Social Sciences bet365 kentucky bonus code Center was unveiled on December 26, 2013。The center is directly affiliated with the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences,Constructed and managed jointly by China Social Sciences Magazine and the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences Library,According to the work plan,We will conduct comprehensive and comprehensive analysis and bet365 kentucky bonus code of my country’s academic journals on a regular basis,Publish relevant bet365 kentucky bonus code report。
Secretary of the Party Committee of the Library of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences、Deputy Director Zhuang Qiansheng thinks,Academic journal bet365 kentucky bonus code is an objective need for journal optimization and development,is necessary,But its guiding role is a "double-edged sword",One-sided use will lead to deviations。Two governance directions can be proposed: First, scientifically construct an academic journal bet365 kentucky bonus code system,Establish a scientific and reasonable system platform that combines qualitative and quantitative methods,Rather than simply using quantitative indicators as a universal standard;The second is to use the journal bet365 kentucky bonus code system scientifically and rationally。The "baton" role of the scientific research management department is sometimes decisive,This requires scientific research management departments not to simply use a single、A “one size fits all” approach to handling complex bet365 kentucky bonus code objects。
Wang Xingguo said,Construction of bet365 kentucky bonus code system and standards for academic journals in humanities and social sciences,Must always focus on the nature of the humanities and social sciences、Characteristics and academic spirit。
Editor-in-Chief of "Chinese National Essence"、Yu Yue, chief researcher of Jiangxi Academy of Social Sciences said,Based on China’s national conditions and academic development,Construct a more reasonable journal bet365 kentucky bonus code system,The same is technological innovation、Part of academic innovation。China’s journal bet365 kentucky bonus code institutions need to make their voices heard internationally,Let the international academic community realize that we can carve out our own path in the bet365 kentucky bonus code of Chinese academic journals。
Friendly links: Official website of Chinese Academy of Social bet365 kentucky bonus code |
Website registration number: Beijing Public Network Security No. 11010502030146 Ministry of Industry and Information Technology: Beijing ICP No. 11013869
All rights reserved by China Social bet365 kentucky bonus code Magazine. No reproduction or use without permission is allowed
Chief editor’s email: zzszbj@126.com Contact information of this website: 010-85886809 Address: Floor 11-12, Building 1, No. 15 Guanghua Road, Chaoyang District, Beijing Postal Code: 100026
>