Two -way Anonymous Promoting Peer Comment is more fair
April 28, 2023 04:30 Source: "China Social Sciences", April 28, 2023, Issue 2641 Author: Practic
Comprehensive foreign media reports The official website of the British Ecology Society recently announced a research results,This study reveals the inequality phenomenon existing in the academic publication process,Compared with two bet365 Play online games -way anonymous and one -way anonymous peer review。Research Discovery,Two -way anonymous mode can effectively reduce bet365 live casino games the prejudice of the reviewer,It is conducive to promoting the process of peer evaluation more fair。
Two -way anonymous peer review means that both the author and the reviewer do not disclose their identity,In an anonymous peer review,The reviewer knows the author's identity。In order to explore whether the author's identity during the peer review process can reduce the prejudice against the author's nationality or gender,The research team used the paper submitted to the "Functional Ecology" magazine in 2019 to 2022,And randomly distribute them into two modes: two bet365 Play online games -way anonymous and one -way anonymous evaluation。
Research Discovery,Under a two -way anonymous mode,The results of the peer reviews obtained by different authors group are similar,In one -way anonymous mode,The results obtained by different authors group show differences。For example, the first author of the paper is a country from low -income countries or low English average levels,The reviewer's score is relatively lower,may be more likely to be required to modify or submit it。No influence of gender differences Bet365 lotto review in different review modes of the two groups brings an impact。
Professor Charles Fox, a professor at Kentucky University in the United States, said,The peer review should be fair and non -prejudiced,This is important for science and scholars,The results of the research are conducive to the publisher's prejudice that may occur during the publishing process。Powerful evidence provided based on this research,The British Ecological Society plans to transition its journal to the compulsory two -way anonymous peer review mode。
(Practicing Zhi Leisure/Compilation)
bet365 Play online games Editor in charge: Changchang