Registration report mode can improve the quality of scientific research
June 30, 2021 11:44 Source: "China Social Sciences" June 30, 2021 Issue 2197 Author: Wang Youran/Compilation

  bet365 best casino games According to a latest study,Academic journals use a registered report mode for peer evaluation before the research starts,It can improve the quality of scientific research while reducing the deviation of the publication。

The Thames Higher Education Website issued a report on June 24th,"Nature · Human Behavior" magazine published a professor of psychology at the University of Virginia in the United States on the same day、Co -founder and Executive Director of the U.S. Non -profit Organization Open Science Center, Brian A. Nosek, and others, the preliminary evidence of the "Preliminary Evidence of the Reading Report Report and Standard Publishing Mode Research Model"。

Bet365 app download According to "practice",Pass reviews Generally occur after the editor of the academic journal receives the submission and the preliminary selection。But a problem followed by it is to publish deviation,The specific result of the research affects the decision of the peer members。For example,Research on a significant result is easier to be published than the research that has not been concluded。In order to reduce the deviation,At present, nearly 300 academic journals have introduced a new poster: Registration report。This mode divides the peer review into two stages,The first stage occurred in the research and design link before data collection and analysis,The second stage occurred in the link of the research report and prepared for publication。Existing research show,The registered report mode can avoid the journal Bet365 lotto review only published those research that verified the original assumptions,Research using this model is similar to the research level of traditional peer evaluation in terms of reference rate。

In order to further understand the impact of the registered report mode on the quality of scientific research,Nortarick and others invite 353 scientific researchers to review the 86 papers in the field of psychology and neuroscience。Among them, Group A (29 articles) uses the registration report mode,Group B (57 articles) The first author of part of the paper is the same as Group A,The remaining papers are published in the same period in the same period and similar themes。Pass reviews at three time points (Research results are known before、After the research results are known、After publishing the paper) Use 19 assessment indicators (including methodological strictness bet365 best casino games and analysis、overall quality、Discussion and results、Novelty、Creativity、Important, etc.) Evaluation。Pass review results,Group A and group B in novelty、Creative and other indicators have almost no difference,Group A in the strictness and analysis of the methodology、The score on the overall quality and other indicators is significantly higher than that of group B。This shows that the registration report mode can improve the quality of scientific research,Enhance the credibility of scientific literature。

According to researchers,The current registered report mode is not widely used。Periodicals introduced into this model are concentrated in the field of neuroscience and social behavior research,But even in these fields,The paper using the registered report mode still belongs to a minority。Nortarick Bet365 app download said,This is not because of the resignation of the registration report mode,but because it is a new thing,Researchers need to work hard to change how to do research、How to report the understanding of research results。Universities can assist in promoting the registration report mode,Promote its advantages to teachers and students,or requires some graduate papers to adopt this mode。

Nozerk thinks,Registration report mode helps "liberating" researchers,Let them focus on the research process,instead of worrying about whether the journal thinks that your research results are worth publishing。What should be treated seriously is the research itself,instead of getting specific results。

  (Wang Youran/Compilation)

Editor in charge: Zong Yue
QR code icons 2.jpg
Key recommendation
The latest article
Graphics
bet365 live casino games
Video

Friendship link: Official Website of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences |

Bet365 app download Website filing number: Jinggong.com Anmi 11010502030146 Ministry of Industry and Information Technology:

All rights reserved by China Social Sciences Magazine shall not be reprinted and used without permission

General Editor Email: zzszbj@126.com This website contact information: 010-85886809 Address: Building 11-12, Building 1, Building 1, No. 15, Guanghua Road, Chaoyang District, Beijing: 100026